Previous Entry Share Next Entry
My own personal ngram
james_nicoll
I joke: I don't get cited in books.

Lifted from yendi

British genre author Christopher Priest is not entirely pleased with the short list for the Clarke Award. Anyone who thinks my comments on the Clarke short list were cranky should check this link to see what true cane-shakery looks like. I am mildly surprised he did not work his way to demanding the entire jury be shot (which for the record I think would be an over-reaction).

He is inexplicably a fan of the idiotic The Testament of Jessie Lamb, which is the sort of Life Boat Rules novel where the characters eventually decide to take the daring step of addressing a leaky life raft by drilling a large hole in the bottom of the boat for the water to flow out. I understand there's a great sympathy in SF for people making hard decisions in bad situations; I just wish the situations did not tend to be contrived and the solutions ludicrous.

Anyway, you can tell he matters far more than I do because while I got comments on More Words, Deeper, he gets replies across the web.

Damien Walter tries the The sour grapes gambit; Priest is displeased because he desired accolades. No attempt is made to deal with Priest's complaints because to do so would be to give credence to them.

Claiming that Priest is motivated by award-jealousy is a jolly daring gambit, given that (as Dan Geiser pointed out), Priest is no stranger to the doleful burden of nominations and wins:

BSFA: 3 Wins, 3 Nominations
Clarke: 1 Win, 2 Nominations
Dimar: 1 Win
Hugo: 1 Nomination
World Fantasy Award: 1 Win



It's also fairly hard to come up with a come back to
heri S. Tepper’s The Waters Rising (Gollancz) – how can one describe it? For fuck’s sake, it is a quest saga and it has a talking horse. There are puns on the word ‘neigh’.

I am bit sad Priest didn't manage to work in a dig at Tepper's apparent fondness for eugenics.

John Scalzi on the other hand goes for more disappointed than angry. He also suggests sticking Priest on next year's jury for the Clarke, out of what I am going to assume is an abiding dislike for the four other jury members.

Mea Culpa: I missed Charles Stross' response. Or rather, I saw it before I saw the context.

I also failed to note that this had made fandomwank.

Also posted at Dreamwidth, where there are comment count unavailable comment(s); comment here or there.

Which woman is most able to use Harlan as raw material in a growthy educational moment for the world?

"As you can see, cracking open a human skull is much harder than it looks, unless you have the proper tools."

That fact has saved my life on more than one occasion.

Re: Iron Critic

(Anonymous)

2012-03-30 12:54 pm (UTC)

K.J. Parker (*). Then she can remove that note from The Belly of the Bow saying she'd made all the types of bow in the book with one obvious exception.

-- Paul Clarke

(*) Unless Parker turns out to be male after all.